Get the model's verified verdict on Plymouth Argyle (and any team you follow) emailed the moment odds drop. Free, no spam, one-click unsubscribe.
Where our probabilities disagree with bookmaker prices.
| Market | Our model | Bookies imply | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plymouth Argyle Win | 51.9% | 60.6% | 9 pts under |
| Over 2.5 Goals | 63.0% | 66.7% | 4 pts under |
What this means: where our model sits above the bookies is where we see value they don't; below means the market already has it priced, no edge there.
Plymouth Argyle 52%, the draw 23%, Barnsley 25%. That's the shape of this one.
Plymouth Argyle have taken 7 points from their last five; Barnsley have won three of their last five. Form gives little away going into this League One tie.
Marginal call: Plymouth Argyle at just 52%. With the draw at 23%, this is anyone's game. You could make a case for Plymouth Argyle, but there's a lot to be said for playing it safe.
Our PickThree or more goals at @1.50. Model probability 63% vs implied 67%. Priced at fair value, so take it for stability rather than edge.
Goals are a tough one to call here. Plymouth Argyle are scoring 1.8 a game (1.8 of those at home) and Barnsley manage 1.4 (1.4 on the road). Add it up and it's basically a coin-flip whether we see three or more, we make it 63%, so there's no strong lean either way on the goals line.
Both teams scoring is the pattern. It happens in 61% of Plymouth Argyle's home games and 65% of Barnsley's away matches.
The complete price grid across all bookmakers.
| Market | Selection | Odds | Probability | Bookmaker |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Match Result | Plymouth Argyle Win | @1.80 | 51.9% | William Hill |
| Match Result | Draw | @3.60 | 23.3% | William Hill |
| Match Result | Barnsley Win | @4.00 | 24.7% | William Hill |
| Goals | Over 2.5 | @1.50 | 63.0% | William Hill |
| Goals | Under 2.5 | @2.40 | 37.0% | William Hill |
Our model makes Plymouth Argyle the favourite with a 51.9% win probability, based on form, head-to-head record and expected goals.
Best available odds: Plymouth Argyle @ 1.80, Draw @ 3.60, Barnsley @ 4.00. We compare multiple bookmakers to find the best value.
Plymouth Argyle vs Barnsley kicks off on Saturday 12 September 2026 at 15:00 in the League One.
Our top prediction is Plymouth Argyle to win. We also rate over/under goals, BTTS, correct score and double chance, every pick is tracked and verified against real outcomes.